Phase II 练习与答案(DFG 第 3 章)
从称呼语、谓体与剩余成分到非限定小句和课堂对话,练习完整的人际结构分析。
语气分析不能停在“找主语和助动词”:还要区分称呼语(Vocative)与主语(Subject),认出限定成分(Finite)和谓体(Predicator)的融合,再把补语(Complement)、附加语(Adjunct)及边界外成分分清。本页覆盖 DFG 第 3 章 Phase II 的 Exercise 1–10 和两段课堂语篇,对应第 4 讲、第 5 讲及第 4 章:作为交换的小句,可返回DFG 本章首页安排学习次序。
练习来源为 DFG 教材 PDF 第 92–98 页(印刷页 82–88);第 99 页已进入 Phase III,不纳入本页。答案据配套 Chapter 3 key 的 PDF 第 6–19 页中 Phase II 部分整理,表格已与页面图像逐项核对。Exercise 3 引用的 Phase I Exercise 6/7 已补查并在此完整列出。
分析前先确定边界
语气成分(Mood)通常由 Subject 与 Finite 构成,也可以容纳语气附加语(Mood Adjunct);剩余成分(Residue)包括 Predicator、Complement 和相应的 Adjunct。评论附加语(Comment Adjunct)与 Mood Adjunct 不是同一类,但“评论附加语”也不能机械地等同于“Mood 外”:本组边界题对 Personally 的处理就需要照 key 单独核对。连接附加语(Conjunctive Adjunct)、Vocative 和感叹语(Expletive)不参与本题的 Mood/Residue 两区。
Exercise 1:区分称呼语与主语
只标 Vocative 和 Subject。先判断一个人名或人称词是在呼唤听者,还是承担该小句的命题责任;不要把句首人名一律标成称呼语。
- Darling, would you carry this for me?
- All of you, get out of here.
- Bruce was inspecting the lab.
- Robin, let's go.
- You really ought to leave straight away.
- Chase had a thing for black rubber.
- Mr Eliot disagreed.
- You had better get ready Alfred.
- Don't, Riddler, even think about it.
- Look at you.
| Darling, | would | you | carry this for me? | |
| Vocative / Subject |
| All of you, | get out of here. | |
| Vocative / Subject |
| Bruce | was inspecting the lab. | |
| Vocative / Subject |
| Robin, | let's | go. | |
| Vocative / Subject |
| You | really ought to leave straight away. | |
| Vocative / Subject |
Exercise 2:主动与被动的语态对应
为每句写出对应的主动式或被动式,尽量保留原句的时态、情态和疑问语气。第 6 题要给两种被动式。这里练的是语态对应(voice agnation),不是只在动词前增加一个 be。
- He'd have walloped her.
- Why won't you tell us?
- The door was shut by Jimmy.
- He squirted his tea back into the cup.
- She'd been won over by the arguments.
- Will I bring you home a few chips?
- My perceptions may be heightened by pregnancy.
Exercise 3:细分剩余成分,并分析省略回应
将 Phase I Exercise 6/7 中六组问答的 Residue 分成 Predicator、Complement 和 Adjunct,同时保留 Subject、Finite 和 Mood/Residue 边界。回应中缺失的 Residue 不要凭语义补写成显式成分。
- Can Tracy watch? — She can of course.
- Abortion's murder. — It is of course.
- You don't care about that. — Yes. I do.
- Dawn has had her baby for Paddy Bell. — She has of course.
- Will all our friends be there? — They will be.
- Your little brother isn't going to like it. — Isn't he?
| Can | Tracy | watch? | |
| 语气结构 | |||
| Mood / Residue 边界 |
| Abortion | 's | murder. | |
| 语气结构 | |||
| Mood / Residue 边界 |
| You | don't | care | about that. | |
| 语气结构 | ||||
| Mood / Residue 边界 |
Exercise 4:找出谓体的完整范围
只标 Subject、Finite 与 Predicator;必要时融合 Finite/Predicator。多个动词形式可以共同实现一个谓体,尤其要留意动词词组复合体(verbal group complex)。
- They are going to sell the house as soon as possible.
- I was expecting to see you earlier.
- He seemed to be perfectly cheerful.
- He was beginning to get into the car.
- Couldn't they have done something about it?
- She might have stopped listening.
- Didn't they try to understand you?
- They started to listen.
| They | are | going to sell | the house as soon as possible. | |
| 语气结构 |
| I | was | expecting to see | you earlier. | |
| 语气结构 |
| He | seemed to be | perfectly cheerful. | |
| 语气结构 |
| He | was | beginning to get | into the car. | |
| 语气结构 |
| Couldn't | they | have done | something about it? | |
| 语气结构 |
Exercise 5:把 Wh 功能与语气结构叠加
标 Subject、Finite、Predicator、Complement、Adjunct。疑问成分(Wh)可以与 Complement 或 Adjunct 融合;第 7 题是感叹式,不能只因含 What 就当疑问句。
- Stop that.
- How did it happen?
- Don't start that.
- Why won't you tell us?
- What do you mean?
- When's it due?
- What a house this is!
| Stop | that. | |
| 语气结构 | ||
| Mood / Residue 边界 |
| How | did | it | happen? | |
| 语气结构 | ||||
| Mood / Residue 边界 |
| Don't | start | that. | |
| 语气结构 | |||
| Mood / Residue 边界 |
| Why | won't | you | tell | us? | |
| 语气结构 | |||||
| Mood / Residue 边界 |
| What | do | you | mean? | |
| 语气结构 | ||||
| Mood / Residue 边界 |
Exercise 6:区分语气附加语与评论附加语
标 Subject、Finite,以及出现的 Mood Adjunct 和 Comment Adjunct,再做分类测验。分类依照 key,不凭“在句首”或中文释义猜测。其余成分在本题暂不细标。
- She was usually seen by someone.
- Frankly, she'd hardly been anywhere.
- She'd already visited some of the sights.
- Apparently she'd barely seen any of the sights in any quarter of the town.
- In general she shopped in some of the fashionable streets.
- Surprisingly, she probably didn't see anyone anymore.
- Provisionally, we might plan a five-day trip.
| She | was | usually | seen by someone. | |
| 语气结构 |
| Frankly, | she | 'd | hardly | been anywhere. | |
| 语气结构 |
| She | 'd | already | visited some of the sights. | |
| 语气结构 |
| Apparently | she | 'd | barely | seen any of the sights in any quarter of the town. | |
| 语气结构 |
- 1.1. She was usually seen by someone. 中 usually 的分类是?
- 2.2. Frankly, she’d hardly been anywhere. 中两项分类正确的是?
- 3.3. She’d already visited some of the sights. 中 already 是?
- 4.4. Apparently she’d barely seen any of the sights in any quarter of the town. 中正确的配对是?
- 5.5. In general she shopped in some of the fashionable streets. 中 In general 的分类是?
- 6.6. Surprisingly, she probably didn’t see anyone anymore. 中正确的配对是?
- 7.7. Provisionally, we might plan a five-day trip. 中哪项符合 key?
Exercise 7:短语动词不等于一个人际成分
标 Mood 与 Residue,再细分 Predicator、Complement、Adjunct。词汇意义上的短语动词(phrasal verb)可能跨越多个人际成分:粒子和介词短语在 key 中仍可单列为 Adjunct。
- Lay off, Veronica.
- I'll sort this fella out.
- They won her over.
- They put her up to it.
- She saw through their plan.
- He watched over the baby.
- She chewed out the opposition.
| Lay | off, | Veronica. | |
| 语气结构 | |||
| Mood / Residue 边界 |
| I | 'll | sort | this fella | out. | |
| 语气结构 | |||||
| Mood / Residue 边界 |
| They | won | her | over. | |
| 语气结构 | ||||
| Mood / Residue 边界 |
| They | put | her | up to it. | |
| 语气结构 | ||||
| Mood / Residue 边界 |
| She | saw | through their plan. | |
| 语气结构 | |||
| Mood / Residue 边界 |
Exercise 8:非限定小句也可能有自己的主语
只分析原题划线的非限定小句(non-finite clause),标 Subject、Predicator、Complement、Adjunct。以下用粗体表示待分析范围;第 1 题含两个小句,均须分析。第 4 题原书未显出下划线,范围按题目与 key 的对应项确认。
- It stood there, rattling, its paws slipping on the formica.
- Tracy came back in with the pup clinging to the front of her jumper.
- Drawn by only two horses, the coach moved slowly down the road.
- Jimmy Sr. wished for Sharon to go out in the hall first.
- He quickly took the King's part, wielding his flail against the attackers.
- Given my aunt by the Duke, the teapot remained a family heirloom for generations.
- He would attempt to repay him by showing him through the royal apartments.
- To give him cause for rejoicing, he granted him sole possession of the farm.
| rattling | |
| 语气结构 | |
| Mood / Residue 边界 |
| its paws | slipping | on the formica | |
| 语气结构 |
| with | the pup | clinging | to the front of her jumper | |
| 语气结构 |
| Drawn | by only two horses | |
| 语气结构 |
| for | Sharon | to go | out | in the hall | first | |
| 语气结构 |
Exercise 9:找出长主语的完整边界
只标主句的 Subject,不分析嵌入小句内部。它可能由长名词词组、名词词组复合体或嵌入小句实现;但“句首出现的长成分”并不保证是 Subject。
- The points that you made there surprised me.
- Your mammy and Sharon and I are having a chat.
- What chance gave, chance took away.
- The increase of empirical knowledge, and more exact modes of thought, made sharper divisions between the sciences inevitable.
- ...the increasingly complex machinery of the State necessitated a more rigorous separation of ranks and occupations.
- The inner unity of human nature was severed too.
- The near identity of these two criticisms of the governmental state can of course be attributed neither to Schiller's prescience nor to the belated character of modern critique.
| The points that you made there | surprised me. | |
| 主句 Subject |
| Your mammy and Sharon and I | are having a chat. | |
| 主句 Subject |
| What chance gave, | chance | took away. | |
| 主句 Subject |
| The increase of empirical knowledge, and more exact modes of thought, | made sharper divisions between the sciences inevitable. | |
| 主句 Subject |
Exercise 10:确定 Mood 与 Residue 的边界
把语篇连接、称呼和感叹成分排除在两区之外,同时保留应该进入 Mood 的附加语。先做前五题,再核对全部九题。
- Gosh, I forgot.
- Tracy, go up to your room.
- I don't think so, Veronica.
- Finally, they all left.
- I didn't meet anyone though.
- Personally, I don't like him.
- Frankly, my dear, I don't give a damn.
- They don't, as a rule, arrive before six.
- They lost, surprisingly.
| Gosh, | I | forgot. | |
| 语气结构 | |||
| Mood / Residue 边界 |
| Tracy, | go up to your room. | |
| 边界外成分 | ||
| Mood / Residue 边界 |
| I | don't | think so, | Veronica. | |
| 语气结构 | ||||
| Mood / Residue 边界 |
| Finally, | they all | left. | |
| 语气结构 | |||
| Mood / Residue 边界 |
| I | didn't | meet anyone | though. | |
| 语气结构 | ||||
| Mood / Residue 边界 |
Text analysis 1:教师组织科学课的课堂话语
学生刚看完有关机械优势的科教片,教师一边写板书一边组织总结。先把原语篇切成小句,标陈述式(declarative)、祈使式(imperative)、是非疑问式(polar interrogative)、Wh 疑问式或小句(minor clause,无完整大句结构的简短话语),再分析人际结构。还要判断:听者合适的回应是给信息、确认信息,还是采取行动?这一步用于辨认语气隐喻(mood metaphor)。
答案表沿用 key 的 1–73 编号,包括简短回应、不完整话语及第 17 句的非限定小句,而不是把每一个 Wh 形式或关系小句都提高到独立话轮。为便于阅读,表中 S = Subject,F = Finite,P = Predicator,C = Complement,A = Adjunct,MA = Mood Adjunct,CA = Comment Adjunct,V = Vocative;F/P 表示融合。M = Mood,R = Residue;“外”列的是两区以外的成分。
教师掌控话语的展开:发出指令、提出问题、确认或评价学生答案,同时用情态和语气隐喻维持较友好的关系。学生熟悉“教师提问—学生回答—教师评价”的顺序,例如第 53–56 句,因此即使大量问题没有完整疑问句形式,也能参与。key 指出学生始终处于回应位置,主要使用 minor 和两个省略陈述,不用祈使、疑问或情态。
主语选择也体现这种控制:key 统计 you 最突出(12 次),包容性的 we/us 为 5 次,片中人物 they/she 为 7 次,所建立分类中的对象仅 3 次。也就是说,课堂并非只是把机器作为客观事物来陈述;教师不断以听者为 Subject,组织学生的注意和行动。
Text analysis 2:学生共同完成器材任务
第二段没有教师直接主持话轮。学生讨论做模型所需的器材:瓶子、螺母、火柴盒、线、软木塞和金属丝。先切分话语,再辨认语气与人际结构,并特别检查第 16 句的提供帮助、第 17 句的不确定省略类型及第 22 句的附加问句(Tag)。
与第一段相比,学生不再只是回答教师的问题。key 的评论概括为:30 个话语单位中仅 5 个 minor,另有 18 个陈述、4 个疑问及 2–3 个祈使;第 17 句的不确定性使祈使数量有范围。第 16 句形式是疑问,实际提供帮助(Offer),可理解为显式主观的意愿调节;第 30 句以带情态的疑问式实现指令(Command)。其余语气与言语功能基本一致。key 概括 Finite 持续体现现在时,强调协商围绕正在进行的任务;原语篇仍有 got 等形式,此处保留原句和逐句表,不为迁就这一总体概括而改写。
key 的 Subject 统计中,13/22 为 we,you 为 5 次,I 为 2 次,指模型的 it 为 2 次。we 的显著地位把任务建构为集体行动:器材与组外人物多出现在 Complement,而信息及物品与服务的协商以参与者自身为中心。对照 Text 1 中突出的 you,就能看见教师控制与同伴合作两种不同的人际组织方式。
自测
- 1.All of you, get out of here. 中 All of you 按本题 key 应标为?
- 2.Will I bring you home a few chips? 的语态对应共有哪两种关键选择?
- 3.He seemed to be perfectly cheerful. 中本题 key 的 Predicator 分析是?
- 4.What do you mean? 中 What 属于?
- 5.She saw through their plan. 中 through their plan 按 key 是?
- 6.its paws slipping on the formica 中哪项正确?
- 7.What chance gave, chance took away. 中主句 Subject 是?
- 8.They don’t, as a rule, arrive before six. 的 Mood 范围是?
- 9.教师说 Steven and Brad, the sun’s shining inside.,期待学生脱帽。这说明什么?
- 10.两段课堂语篇中的 Subject 选择,哪项符合 key 的结论?