Phase II 练习与答案(DFG 第 4 章)
十六组参与者与过程辨析练习,六篇及物性语篇分析,附交互标注、逐句答案与自测。
过程类型只是入口:真正的及物性(Transitivity)分析还要解释“谁以什么角色参与、背景怎样进入小句、思想或话语是否另成小句”。这一 Phase 把参与者角色、关系过程的两种模式、过程边界测试和环境成分(Circumstance)的层级区分结合起来,再用六篇不同体裁的语篇检验分析。可先复习第 6 讲、第 7 讲、第 8 讲和全书第 5 章:表征,回到DFG 本章首页比较各 Phase 的任务。
先把三个层面分开
参与者(participant)是某类过程必需或可扩展的角色;环境成分在小句层面规定时间、地点、方式、原因等;名词词组内部的修饰成分则只限定某个参与者。一个介词短语可能落在任意层面。“涉及一个人”不是参与者测试,“表示时间”也不保证是时间环境成分:spent the next nine years 在 key 中把时间构建成 Scope。
行为过程(behavioural)与心理、言语过程的边界,需要联合无标记时态、意识性、Receiver 与投射(projection)测试。测试针对特定语境,不是给某个动词永久贴一张标签。答案中的空白不是“漏了一词”,而是本题没有要求该层功能,或该成分纯属语篇/人际。下表原样保留 key 的主要答案;key 没有展开的内层细标明确注明“本站补析”。
Exercise 1:物质与心理过程的参与者
回到 Phase I 的 Exercise 4,为各句标出动作者(Actor)、目标(Goal)、感知者(Senser)与现象(Phenomenon)。题句在这里重列;先做前四句,再核对全部十句。
- The ruffians robbed him.
- The king retreated to a nearby bridge.
- The farmer saw the battle.
- The farmer wanted a farm of his own.
- Kinsmen performed the service for 300 years.
- The king was amused by his wonder and comment.
- Nothing could please me more.
- ... whenever the king should pass over the land.
- How will I recognise the king?
- Willie suddenly realised the true rank of the man.
| The ruffians | robbed | him | |
| 及物性 |
| The king | retreated | to a nearby bridge | |
| 及物性 |
| The farmer | saw | the battle | |
| 及物性 |
| The farmer | wanted | a farm of his own | |
| 及物性 |
心理过程的主语不一定是 Senser:第 7 句 Nothing 引起感受,me 才是体验者。第 6 句被动式仍是心理过程,不应把 by 后的原因误贴成 Actor。第 5 句 the service 按 key 标为 Goal。
Exercise 2:心理与言语过程的参与者
重做 Phase I 的 Exercise 5,标感知者、现象、讲话者(Sayer)与讲话内容(Verbiage)。引语是另一个小句层面的投射,不自动等于名词性 Verbiage。
- James wanted his uncle’s sword.
- Willie eagerly agreed.
- James asked a question.
- James decided on peace.
- Willie answered slowly.
- James heard things about the feuding chieftains.
- He liked the simple pleasures.
- “Easily”, replied his companion.
- Willie suddenly realised the true rank of the man.
- “His hat”, repeated his escort.
| James | wanted | his uncle’s sword | |
| 及物性 |
| Willie | eagerly | agreed | |
| 及物性 |
| James | asked | a question | |
| 及物性 |
| James | decided on | peace | |
| 及物性 |
eagerly、slowly、suddenly 不是本题要求的参与者。key 在第 8、10 句只给 his companion / his escort 标 Sayer,未把引语标成 Verbiage。
Exercise 3:接受者、服务对象与环境成分
判断指定短语是接受者(Recipient)、服务对象(Client)、受话者(Receiver)还是环境成分(Circumstance)。尝试去掉介词并移到过程后:可产生对应双宾结构是本题的诊断。
- He granted sole possession of the farm to Willie.
- All the children ran up to her.
- She was thirsty for a drink.
- He poured a glass of milk for her.
- Father Christmas’s box of clothes was brought to your house.
- She made a good dinner for her.
- And I shall creep very quietly to the spare room.
- She trained hard for the race.
- She poured a drink for her sister.
- He sent some money to his friend.
- She worked hard for her mother.
- 1.1. He granted sole possession of the farm to Willie. 判断:to Willie
- 2.2. All the children ran up to her. 判断:to her
- 3.3. She was thirsty for a drink. 判断:for a drink
- 4.4. He poured a glass of milk for her. 判断:for her
- 5.5. Father Christmas’s box of clothes was brought to your house. 判断:to your house
- 6.6. She made a good dinner for her. 判断:for her
- 7.7. And I shall creep very quietly to the spare room. 判断:to the spare room
- 8.8. She trained hard for the race. 判断:for the race
- 9.9. She poured a drink for her sister. 判断:for her sister
- 10.10. He sent some money to his friend. 判断:to his friend
- 11.11. She worked hard for her mother. 判断:for her mother
本组没有 Receiver 的正例。表示人的短语也可能只是环境成分,如 for her mother;不能仅凭“为谁”判 Client。
Exercise 4:识别式与属性式
区分关系过程的属性式(attributive)与识别式(identifying);若为识别式,再写出参与者倒序的对应句。
- His mother was the regent.
- The lion represents courage.
- James became adventurous and resourceful.
- At 16 he was an experienced fighter.
- He was both wise and good.
- His name was Willie.
- That was only a foolish dream.
- Which one are you?
- The king must be either you or me.
- All but the two of us are bareheaded.
- 1.1. His mother was the regent.
- 2.2. The lion represents courage.
- 3.3. James became adventurous and resourceful.
- 4.4. At 16 he was an experienced fighter.
- 5.5. He was both wise and good.
- 6.6. His name was Willie.
- 7.7. That was only a foolish dream.
- 8.8. Which one are you?
- 9.9. The king must be either you or me.
- 10.10. All but the two of us are bareheaded.
倒序不是机械交换主语与表语:represents 要相应转成 is represented by;疑问句和情态句也应保留各自的语法条件。
Exercise 5:找出存在物
标出存在物(Existent),注意存在小句未必带 there,句首的地点也不是存在物。
- In his hand there was a royal sceptre.
- There will be a continuing struggle.
- In the townships, there had been a riot.
- There was a rose in the vase.
- On the table lay some tattered books.
| In his hand | there | was | a royal sceptre | |
| 及物性 |
| There | will be | a continuing struggle | |
| 及物性 |
| In the townships | there | had been | a riot | |
| 及物性 |
| There | was | a rose | in the vase | |
| 及物性 |
There 是存在句的语法占位项,没有参与者功能。第 5 句的 lay 表示书的存在及位置,存在物是 some tattered books。
Exercise 6:用受话者与意识性区分心理和言语
尝试加入 Receiver,并把主动参与者换成非意识事物。言语过程不要求 Sayer 必须有意识,心理过程的 Senser 则以意识性为条件。
- They didn’t explain that we needed to pay in advance.
- We always expect a quick response.
- Please consider all the options carefully.
- They suggested that there were alternative flights.
- They promised that there would be a short interval.
- We believe it’s the best idea.
- They understand that they won’t be able to stay.
- They insisted that portable computers would not be insured.
- 1.1. They didn’t explain that we needed to pay in advance.
- 2.2. We always expect a quick response.
- 3.3. Please consider all the options carefully.
- 4.4. They suggested that there were alternative flights.
- 5.5. They promised that there would be a short interval.
- 6.6. We believe it’s the best idea.
- 7.7. They understand that they won’t be able to stay.
- 8.8. They insisted that portable computers would not be insured.
解释不能只看 that 后面是否出现小句;两类过程都可投射,必须联合角色结构与意识性测试。
Exercise 7:行为与心理过程的两项诊断
先不受题句现有时态影响,考虑“此刻正在进行”的无标记时态(unmarked tense),再判断能否投射所想的内容。key 中 present 指一般现在时,present in present 指现在进行时。
- The baby was watching me.
- No one will notice.
- She knew the reason for his silence.
- He pondered the situation.
- Jamie hadn’t remembered.
- Listen to this.
- They all looked round.
- I could smell the roses.
- 1.1. The baby was watching me.
- 2.2. No one will notice.
- 3.3. She knew the reason for his silence.
- 4.4. He pondered the situation.
- 5.5. Jamie hadn’t remembered.
- 6.6. Listen to this.
- 7.7. They all looked round.
- 8.8. I could smell the roses.
watch / notice、look / see、listen / hear 不能靠词义相近而归成同类:本题关注感知活动与感知经验的构形差异。
Exercise 8:行为与言语过程的投射测试
检查过程能否报告另一个小句:可以报告者判 verbal;只构建发声或评价活动者按本题 key 判 behavioural。
- They all talked at once.
- They were singing at the top of their lungs.
- Jamie agreed.
- The barometer says rain.
- The baby was screaming its head off.
- Everyone praised him.
- They stated their beliefs.
- She spoke loudly and firmly.
- 1.1. They all talked at once.
- 2.2. They were singing at the top of their lungs.
- 3.3. Jamie agreed.
- 4.4. The barometer says rain.
- 5.5. The baby was screaming its head off.
- 6.6. Everyone praised him.
- 7.7. They stated their beliefs.
- 8.8. She spoke loudly and firmly.
不能把一切“嘴巴做的事”当 verbal,也不要把此处对某一用法的判断推广到一个动词的所有语境。
Exercise 9:行为者、范围与指向对象
按题目的行为过程分析框架标行为者(Behaver)、范围(Scope),必要时称行为(Behaviour),以及指向对象(Target)。
- She has described the problem clearly.
- He insulted his audience.
- He was talking rubbish.
- She flattered her teacher.
- They uttered a cry of joy.
- He slandered his rival.
- She blamed the judges.
- She gave a speech.
- He smiled a most compelling smile.
- He pondered the problem.
| She | has described | the problem | clearly | |
| 及物性 |
| He | insulted | his audience | |
| 及物性 |
| He | was talking | rubbish | |
| 及物性 |
| She | flattered | her teacher | |
| 及物性 |
Target 是受到侮辱、奉承、诋毁、责备等行为指向的人;Scope 则表达行为的内容或展开。第 8、9 句 a speech / a smile 重述行为,可称 Behaviour。请保留 key 对 described、talking、pondered 的这一组分析,不用其他语境的过程标签覆盖它。
Exercise 10:心理经验与关系属性
区分心理过程与关系属性式;检验情绪/认知是过程本身,还是被赋予载体的状态。
- I didn’t know.
- The play upset him.
- I wasn’t aware of that.
- The children could see from a distance.
- Joanna was very upset.
- But I didn’t notice him.
- None of the children believed it except Sylvia.
- Sylvia always had good ideas.
- I’ve never felt so irritated.
- 1.1. I didn’t know.
- 2.2. The play upset him.
- 3.3. I wasn’t aware of that.
- 4.4. The children could see from a distance.
- 5.5. Joanna was very upset.
- 6.6. But I didn’t notice him.
- 7.7. None of the children believed it except Sylvia.
- 8.8. Sylvia always had good ideas.
- 9.9. I’ve never felt so irritated.
Exercise 11:发生、出现与属性变化
区分物质过程(material)和关系属性式。状态变化也可能是关系过程,关键是有无 Carrier—Attribute 构形。
- The play begins at six.
- She became upset.
- The paint turned brown.
- The term ends in November.
- A problem arose with that solution.
- It goes bad sometimes.
- It goes sour in the heat.
- A bridge appeared in the distance.
- 1.1. The play begins at six.
- 2.2. She became upset.
- 3.3. The paint turned brown.
- 4.4. The term ends in November.
- 5.5. A problem arose with that solution.
- 6.6. It goes bad sometimes.
- 7.7. It goes sour in the heat.
- 8.8. A bridge appeared in the distance.
Exercise 12:范围与目标
每句先找出相关参与者,再判断它是 Scope 还是 Goal。范围规定活动的领域或重述过程;目标作为被影响、改变或产生的实体参与。
- We’re doing “The Coventry Carol”.
- He ran a terrific race.
- He pulled his little broken wing along.
- Why did they tear it up?
- He made a nest.
- They crossed the muddy river.
- They had a game of catch.
- They licked their fingers.
- He played the piano beautifully.
- The Sergeant kicked another cannon ball.
- They climbed the wall.
- He had the best dinner ever.
- 1.1. We’re doing “The Coventry Carol”. 判断:“The Coventry Carol”
- 2.2. He ran a terrific race. 判断:a terrific race
- 3.3. He pulled his little broken wing along. 判断:his little broken wing
- 4.4. Why did they tear it up? 判断:it
- 5.5. He made a nest. 判断:a nest
- 6.6. They crossed the muddy river. 判断:the muddy river
- 7.7. They had a game of catch. 判断:a game of catch
- 8.8. They licked their fingers. 判断:their fingers
- 9.9. He played the piano beautifully. 判断:the piano
- 10.10. The Sergeant kicked another cannon ball. 判断:another cannon ball
- 11.11. They climbed the wall. 判断:the wall
- 12.12. He had the best dinner ever. 判断:the best dinner ever
key 第 6 句将原题缩写成 He crossed the river,角色仍是 Scope;本页保留教材的 They crossed the muddy river。第 12 句 dinner 按 key 是活动范围,不按吃掉食物的字面推理改成 Goal。
Exercise 13:识别式中的标记与价值
为每个关系识别式标出标记(Token)和价值(Value)。完整名词词组、名词化小句或嵌入小句可以实现一个参与者。
- What was the last item on the program?
- Garden maintenance is his responsibility.
- Now was the time for everyone to join in.
- The basic mechanism is one where the teacher surveils the student.
- The substantial cost of the program is the only disadvantage.
- The view of English that I have developed represents a minority position.
- It was the best concert ever.
- One of the results is that real differences are obscured.
- What is immediately striking is the manner in which it works.
- The exercise doesn’t involve composing a written response.
- My birthday is today.
| What | was | the last item on the program | |
| 及物性 |
| Garden maintenance | is | his responsibility | |
| 及物性 |
| Now | was | the time for everyone to join in | |
| 及物性 |
| The basic mechanism | is | one where the teacher surveils the student | |
| 及物性 |
第 4、8、9、11 句都是 Value 在前。My birthday 给定待定位的日子,而 today 是其具体对应项。key 第 5 句写 project,教材写 program;这里保留教材题句,不影响 Token / Value 答案。
Exercise 14:属性式的三种类型
标载体(Carrier)与属性(Attribute),再判断内包型(intensive)、拥有型(possessive)或环境型(circumstantial)。地点在环境型属性式中可以成为参与者,不是游离的背景。
- He was in the phone booth.
- It was a tracksuit.
- He grew thoughtful.
- Has he got a plan?
- The fare seems exorbitant.
- That’s easy.
- He had a sore head.
- Where’s our lunch?
- Here are his paw marks.
| He | was | in the phone booth | |
| 及物性 |
| It | was | a tracksuit | |
| 及物性 |
| He | grew | thoughtful | |
| 及物性 |
| Has | he | got | a plan | |
| 及物性 |
- 1.1. He was in the phone booth.
- 2.2. It was a tracksuit.
- 3.3. He grew thoughtful.
- 4.4. Has he got a plan?
- 5.5. The fare seems exorbitant.
- 6.6. That’s easy.
- 7.7. He had a sore head.
- 8.8. Where’s our lunch?
- 9.9. Here are his paw marks.
第 8、9 句 Attribute 在前;Here are his paw marks 在本练习按环境型属性式分析,不因“这里有……”的中文译法改判存在过程。
Exercise 15:投射思想、话语与嵌入参与者
标出各层参与者和环境成分,区分思想(idea)、话语(locution)与降阶嵌入(embedding)。只有嵌入小句才可能作为外层参与者;独立被投射小句不要贴 Phenomenon / Verbiage。
- They love ice-cream.
- They don’t like us taking this.
- I want you to have it.
- She repeated the answer.
- I wish there was someone to talk to.
- Are you quite sure you’re not imagining it?
- We’ve all been wondering where you disappeared to.
- “But we’ll get cold,” said Rachel.
- I told everyone to leave.
- The toy amused her.
- I don’t even know if her family exchanges gifts at Christmas.
- It was wonderful to be wrapped in paper with pictures on it.
| They | love | ice-cream | |
| 及物性 |
| They | don’t like | [[us | taking | this]] | |
| 及物性 | |||||
| 嵌入小句 | |||||
| I | want | you | to have | it | |
| 及物性 | |||||
| 投射地位 | |||||
| 被投射小句 | |||||
| She | repeated | the answer | |
| 及物性 |
第 2 句是嵌入行为,外层可用 Phenomenon:act 覆盖整个小句;第 3、5、7、11 句是 idea,第 8、9 句是 locution。第 6 句事实小句充当 Matter:fact,不是投射;原 key 内层只标 Senser(it 的 Phenomenon 是可进一步补析的成分)。第 12 句不要将形式上的 It 独立当作完整意义载体。
Exercise 16:环境成分与其他层级成分
标参与者与环境成分;尤其检验介词短语是在小句层面修饰过程,还是留在名词词组内部,以及原因关系是否由另一小句实现。
- On Christmas eve, he crept out to his woolshed.
- He ran away out of fear.
- He had a surprise for them all.
- The sledge began moving, because the ground sloped down.
- They saw some toys in the sack.
- In no time at all, he made a top.
- They ate the icing on the cake.
- They ate the icing off the cake.
- What did the youngsters say on your arrival?
- Can I see the presents you got from Santa?
| On Christmas eve | he | crept | out | to his woolshed | |
| 及物性 |
| He | ran | away | out of fear | |
| 及物性 |
| He | had | a surprise | for them all | |
| 及物性 |
| The sledge | began moving | because | the ground | sloped | down | |
| 及物性 |
on the cake 在第 7 句限定 icing,是 Goal 内部修饰语;第 8 句 off the cake 表达吃的来源位置,是小句环境成分。第 10 句 from Santa 留在修饰 presents 的关系小句内部;不能越过层级直接挂到 see。
Text analysis 1:给儿童的声音解释
沿用 DFG 第 3 章的解释语篇,细分心理和行为过程。分析后讨论:作者是在定义声音,还是在引导儿童通过活动和感知形成认识?下列编号沿用教材,投射/依存关系词留在句内;双方括号表示嵌入。
- 1 Do you enjoy [[making sounds]]?
- 2.1 What sounds do these things make
- 2.2 if you bang them?
- 3 What different sounds can you make with your body and your voice?
- 4.1 Put your fingers on your throat
- 4.2 as you talk
- 4.3 or [as you] sing.
- 5 What can you feel?
- 6 Hold a ruler on the edge of a table.
- 7.1 Press down the end
- 7.2 and let go.
- 8 Can you hear a sound?
- 9 What do you see?
- 10.1 Whenever you hear a sound
- 10.2 there is [[something moving]].
- 11 This movement is called a vibration.
- 12.1 Try this with a rubber band
- 12.2 and see.
- 13.1 You can make musical sounds with rubber bands of different sizes
- 13.2 or by plucking the strings of a guitar.
- 14 Strike a triangle with a beater.
- 15.1 Touch the triangle
- 15.2 while it is ringing.
- 16 What can you feel?
- 17.1 When something stops vibrating
- 17.2 the sound stops.
- 18 How does someone’s voice reach you?
- 19 The sound travels through the air as sound waves.
- 20 Throw a stone in a pool of water.
- 21 Watch [[the waves spreading out]].
- 22 Sound waves move through the air in a similar way.
key 的结论是:这篇解释更大篇幅构建读者的动作和感知,而不是直接描述声音。祈使句要求儿童完成物质活动,随后心理过程的疑问句询问感受,再由存在、识别和以声音作 Actor 的陈述句提炼知识。talk 与 sing 在这里是儿童必须做的身体发声活动,所以归 behavioural:verbal;vibration 则以 Token 身份成为技术名称。
方式中的手段与地点规定实验“怎样做、在哪里做”;声音的移动也依赖地点表达。Role:guise 引入 sound waves,Manner:comparison 又把这个术语与可观察的水波联系起来。
Text analysis 2:儿童故事 My place 的开篇
把 1988 年的故事开篇切成小句,分析过程、参与者和环境成分,讨论这些选择怎样构建“我”和“我的地方”。句间投射用表中说明识别,省略的小句不删除。语篇标题 1988 也是 Location:time。
- 1 My name’s Laura
- 2 and this is my place.
- 3 I turned ten last week.
- 4 Our house is the one with the flag on the window.
- 5 Tony says
- 6 it shows
- 7 we’re on Aboriginal land,
- 8 but I think
- 9 it means the colour of the earth, back home.
- 10 Mum and Dad live here too,
- 11 and Terry and Lorraine, and Aunty Bev, and Tony and Diane and their baby Dean.
- 12 He’s my nephew
- 13 and he’s so cute!
- 14 We come from Bourke,
- 15 but Dad thought
- 16 there’d be more jobs in the city.
- 17 This [picture] is me and Gully.
- 18 I have to keep her on a lead
- 19 because she chases cars.
- 20 She comes from Bourke too.
- 21 I guess
- 22 she thinks
- 23 they’re sheep.
- 24 This is a map of my place.
- 25 We’ve got a McDonalds right on the corner!
key 把开篇看作身份与地方的定向:识别式确定名字、住宅、图像和旗帜意义,属性式描述年龄、亲属关系、性格和地点。家庭成员既分别作 Actor、Senser、Sayer、Carrier,也与叙述者共同构成 we;儿童的身份嵌入家庭,而不是一个孤立的个人。地点常常进入属性式的参与者位置,突出原住民身份与地方归属。
We come from Bourke 按 key 是关系式,近于 we are from Bourke;一般现在时及整段的关系性倾向支持这一读法。I have to keep her on a lead 按使役关系式分析,I 是赋属性者(Attributor);也可改按物质式,I = Actor、her = Goal、on a lead = Manner。He’s my nephew 被读作“我的一个侄子”,所以是属性式;若强调唯一的那个侄子,则可成为识别式。
Text analysis 3:亲子对话:鸟为什么会死
M 为母亲,C 为四岁半儿童;以下按轮次给每个小句新编号(不是教材编号),保留插入、投射、停顿与省略。先标经验结构,再检查哪些成分只是语篇性或人际性。
- C1 How could birds die?
- M1 [One] Like the one in the garden, are you thinking of?
- M2 Well, sometimes birds die
- M3 when they get very old,
- M4 or maybe they get sick
- M5 because they got some disease,
- M6 or maybe a cat got it.
- M7 Baby birds sometimes die
- M8 when they fall out of the nest,
- M9 or, in the winter birds might die
- M9i
<<if you were in a cold place>> - M10 because they can’t get enough food.
- C2 Yeah, but what happens
- C3 if one bird falls out
- C4 and then – and when it’s just about at the ground
- C5 it flies?
- M11 Yes, well if it’s big enough [[to fly]]
- M12 it’ll be all right.
- M13 And sometimes birds fall out of the nest
- M14 but they don’t die...
- M15 But that didn’t look like a baby bird;
- M16 maybe there was something wrong with it;
- M17 maybe a cat killed it –
- M18 (hastily) I don’t think
- M19 it was our cat.
- C6 Perhaps it was on the ground
- C7 and then a cat got it.
- M20 Yeah, it was probably pecking something on the ground...
- M21 Maybe it was just a very old bird.
- C8 But it looks as if it’s alive.
- M22 Yeah, it does [ ], doesn’t it?
- C9 Perhaps its eye got blind.
- M23 Could have been [ ],
- M24 but it definitely wasn’t alive.
key 指出,物质过程与关系属性式特别突出。鸟交替被构建为泛指的鸟、假设的一只鸟和双方记忆中的具体死鸟;物质式中作 Actor,属性式中作 Carrier。猫出现时是 Actor,鸟转为 Goal。鸟很少对其他实体采取行动:它被表述为处在某地、移动、死亡或受到影响;两次有 Goal 的鸟的活动中,一次还是“无法得到足够食物”。
属性式常是环境型,位置或比较方式被当作 Attribute 探索。Well、Yeah、maybe、perhaps、probably、definitely、and、but、when、because 等不另获经验角色;key 对 sometimes 也不标环境功能。M20 的 on the ground 留在整个 Goal 中,不能仅因介词短语出现就拆成环境成分。
Text analysis 4:杂志特写 Dangerous liaisons
这是 Phase I 杂志语篇的加长原版。按下列顺序重做全部小句,关注女性、囚犯、志愿者和机构代表分别获得什么角色。方括号内的省略恢复由本站加注;非降阶的 who 关系小句也分行分析。
- 1 Women [[who form relationships with prisoners]] often believe
- 2 they alone understand the men,
- 3 and [they] can reform them.
- 4 They say,
- 5 I know this guy;
- 6 I know
- 7 he’s good.
- 8 It’s partly a nurturing instinct,
- 9 but some prisoners are also very physically attractive and charming,
- 10 notes Sister Janet Glass,
- 11 who works with a Catholic chaplaincy team at Sydney’s Long Bay jail.
- 12 Often, these women are attracted to prisoners
- 13 because they have just ended a relationship,
- 14 Glass adds.
- 15 They’re empty,
- 16 and [they] want some sort of emotional fillip.
- 17 The prisoners are probably lying to them,
- 18 but they appear gallant and masculine
- 19 and women believe them.
- 20 Prison Fellowship is an interdenominational organisation with its own programs and volunteers.
- 20i (see main story)
- 21 Although [PF is] seen as independent,
- 22 PF has received financial support from the Baptist Church
- 23 and its director, Ross Coleman, was a welfare worker with Baptist Community Services.
- 24 Coleman says
- 25 PF volunteers must provide character references
- 26 and [PF volunteers] undergo a training program
- 27 before [PF volunteers] starting the work.
- 28 Volunteers use pseudonyms in letters
- 29 and prisoners’ replies are sent to PF headquarters
- 30 and then [prisoners’ replies are] re-directed.
- 31 The forming of emotional attachments with prisoners is forbidden.
- 32 Coleman admits
- 33 that volunteers [[who transgress]] would only be detected
- 34 if they told us,
- 35 so sometimes that could happen
- 36 and we were oblivious to it,
- 37 which is always a risk...
- 38 He says
- 39 PF is particularly concerned with Christian prisoners, or prisoners [[who have found Christ whilst in prison]].
- 40 Not unexpectedly, mainstream churches often criticise the influence of pentecostal or charismatic Christian groups within the penal system.
- 41 Some PF volunteers want to baptise prisoners after one week,
- 42 says Sister Glass.
- 43 Some pentecostal types raise emotional levels to an extraordinary degree,
- 44 then [they] leave prisoners to deal with the realities of prison life,
- 45 which can be dangerous,
- 46 says Sister Glass.
- 47 Born again prisoners believe
- 48 they can wipe out all memory of their crimes,
- 49 because Jesus has forgiven them.
key 认为四种主要过程分布相当均衡,另有两个 behavioural:verbal;整体约四分之三不是物质过程,重点是信念、说法和属性,而非行动。前两段主要构建女性的认知与囚犯的属性/行为,现实版本又几乎都经 Sister Glass 的言语过程转述。第三段转向 Prison Fellowship,Sayer 换成主任 Coleman,他通过连续物质式呈现志愿者的工作,女性作 Actor,信件作 Goal。
报道容纳多种视角,但女性和囚犯即使获 Sayer 或言语性 Behaver,也多经机构代表“再转述”。Sister Glass 几乎只作 Sayer,从不作 Receiver 或 Target,且占有最多发言角色。分析不仅是数过程,还要看谁能说、谁只能被说。
key 的七条说明需要连同答案读:第 12 句 attracted to 近于 susceptible to,故属性式;换成 attracted by 则 key 建议物质过程、prisoners 为 Actor。第 17 句原版 lying 不能投射另一小句,故行为过程;Phase I 改写为 telling lies 后则是 verbal + Verbiage。第 20 句作为组织定义按识别式,但 key 承认与属性式边界难定。第 22 句 PF 在语法上是 Actor,不是 Recipient。第 31 句 forbid 能带 Receiver、也可投射命令,故按被动言语式;另一读法是 Carrier + is + forbidden / undesirable 的属性式。第 39 句 particularly 支持关系状态读法。第 41 句 want to baptise 按动词词组复合体体现一个物质过程;也可切为先 mental、后 material 两句。
Text analysis 5:防鸟网的操作程序
分析树莓种植说明,既处理主干小句,也进入 key 给出的嵌入层。2e、3e、10e、11e、13e 表示嵌入,不是新的主干语篇步骤;2c 是 key 恢复的比较省略结构。
- 1 Blackbirds take the heaviest toll of raspberries.
- 2 They are more troublesome in gardens [[where there is plenty of cover [[to nest in]], and fewer plants [[to feed from]]]],
- 2e [[where there is plenty of cover [[to nest in]], and fewer plants [[to feed from]]]]
- 2c than [they are troublesome] in large open raspberry fields.
- 3 Unless you can devise a really efficient way [[of scaring them]],
- 3e [[of scaring them]]
- 4 you will have to net.
- 5 To support the net,
- 6 make a framework of wires or canes fixed to posts over the row.
- 7 Cover the tops of the posts with polythene or jam jars
- 8 so that the net can be pulled smoothly over them
- 9 without snagging.
- 10 Alternatively, buy more expensive supports [[which slot together to form a rigid frame]].
- 10e1 [[which slot together
- 10e2 to form a rigid frame]]
- 11 The net should be high enough above the row [[to prevent birds sitting on the top and pecking through]];
- 11e1 [[to prevent birds sitting on the top
- 11e2 and [birds] pecking through]]
- 12 it must hang well clear of the sides
- 13 as fruit is carried on side shoots [[growing out from the canes]].
- 13e [[growing out from the canes]]
这篇程序把读者构建为行动者:devise、net、support、make、cover、buy 形成问题—条件—操作链,网和支架多为 Goal。手段、质量和地点使指令能实际执行;so that 和 without 通过依存小句说明效果或要避免的事件,而不是把所有语义上的原因或方式都压成环境标签。
两处关于网的关系属性式提出设计条件;nest、feed、scaring、slot、form、prevent ... sitting 和 growing 进入嵌入层,把环境、用途及部件特征装进名词词组或 Attribute。key 没有另写语篇结论,上述两段是本站据其分析归纳。
Text analysis 6:萧伯纳的生平重述
沿时间线切分传记,逐句标过程、参与者和环境成分。关系小句 which / where 不省去;书名列表留在同一个参与者内。
- 1 George Bernard Shaw was born in Dublin, Ireland, on July 26, 1856.
- 2 He attended four different schools
- 3 but his real education came from a thorough grounding in music and painting,
- 4 which he obtained at home.
- 5 In 1871, he was apprenticed to a Dublin estate agent,
- 6 and later he worked as a cashier.
- 7 In 1876, Shaw joined his mother and sister in London,
- 8 where he spent the next nine years in unrecognised struggle and genteel poverty.
- 9 From 1885 to 1898, he wrote for newspapers and magazines as critic of art, literature, music and drama.
- 10 But his main interest at this time was political propaganda,
- 11 and, in 1884, he joined the Fabian Society.
- 12 From 1893 to 1939, the most active period of his career, Shaw wrote 47 plays.
- 13 By 1915, his international fame was firmly established
- 14 and productions of Candida, Man and Superman, Arms and the Man, The Devil’s Disciple, were being played in many countries of the world, from Britain to Japan.
- 15 In 1925, the playwright was awarded the Nobel Prize for Literature.
- 16 Between the ages of fifty-seven and sixty-seven, Shaw wrote such dramas as Heartbreak House, Back to Methuselah, Androcles and the Lion, St. Joan.
- 17 During his lifetime he was besieged by offers to film his plays,
- 18 but he accepted only a few,
- 19 the most notable being Pygmalion,
- 20 which was adapted (after his death) as the basis for the musical My Fair Lady.
- 21 He died at the age of ninety-four at Ayot St. Lawrence, England, on November 2, 1950.
物质过程为生平构建事件线,而句首日期不断重新定位活动:受教育、工作、加入组织、写作、获奖直到死亡。被动式的 Shaw 不总是 Goal:第 15 句获奖时是 Recipient,奖项才是 Goal;作品上演时按 key 是 Scope。wrote 在此按创造文字作品的物质过程分析,不能见“写”就机械判 verbal。
少量关系式用来识别政治兴趣、最突出的作品或描写名望。for newspapers and magazines 是 Client,as a cashier / as critic 是 Role,而 the next nine years 在 spent 的构形中是 Scope,不因表达时间就改成 Extent。key 没有另写这一篇的结论,上述两段为本站据其标注归纳。
自测
- 1.Nothing could please me more 中,me 是什么角色?
- 2.He poured a glass of milk for her 中,for her 按本练习是什么?
- 3.下列哪组与 Exercise 7 的两项测试一致?
- 4.My birthday is today 的 Token / Value 顺序是什么?
- 5.I want you to have it 中,you to have it 的外层地位是什么?
- 6.多选哪些判断符合 Exercise 16 的 key?
- 7.声音解释中 This movement is called a vibration 如何分析?
- 8.萧伯纳传记中 the playwright was awarded the Nobel Prize ... 的主语角色是什么?